Alabama House Fails To Pass Bill To End Judicial Override In Capital Cases

I shouldn’t be surprised.  Alabama is one of only four states that permit judges to override jury recommendations in capital cases, and it is the only one of the four that chooses judges in partisan elections.  And 90% of the time, the override goes in the direction of imposing the death penalty when the jury has recommended life.

Rep. Demetrius Newton (D-Birmingham) had proposed a bill that would require judges to follow the juries’ recommendation in these cases, but the House failed yesterday to pass a Budget Isolation Resolution that would have permitted a vote on the bill, effectively killing it.

Rep. Demetrius Newton, D-Birmingham, the bill’s sponsor, said he believes circuit judges too often impose the death penalty when juries recommend life in prison because of political pressure. Judges are elected in Alabama.

But Rep. Allen Treadaway, R-Morris, said judges need to override juries when they clearly disregard the law and suggest an improper punishment.

Oh, please.  This is Alabama, where over 70% of the population strongly supports the death penalty.  Not only that, I’m pretty sure that prosecutors “death qualify” juries, excluding those who would refuse to vote for the death penalty under any circumstances.  (Wheeler, feel free to jump in here as this is your area of expertise).  So just how likely is it that Alabama juries are going to be soft on crime?

And how likely is it that Alabama judges will override a jury recommendation of death when they know that their opponents in the next election will paint them as criminal-loving bleeding heart weenies?

Let’s face it — most criminal defendants in Alabama don’t have the resources to hire Johnny Cochran.  Alabama jurors aren’t likely to be dazzled by the star power of defense attorneys.  If they convict a defendant of a capital crime, they’re already predisposed to impose the death penalty.  If they recommend a life sentence instead, they probably have good reason for doing so.  And they don’t have to run for re-election.

But legislators do.

****

Wheeler and Dan have posted on this story as well.

11 Responses to “Alabama House Fails To Pass Bill To End Judicial Override In Capital Cases”

  1. Wheeler says:

    “I’m pretty sure that prosecutors “death qualify” juries, excluding those who would refuse to vote for the death penalty under any circumstances.”

    you’re right; everyone on the jury is pro-death penalty to some degree.

    “most criminal defendants in Alabama don’t have the resources to hire Johnny Cochran. Alabama jurors aren’t likely to be dazzled by the star power of defense attorneys.”

    the problem is more than just a lack of slick attorneys. the lack of resources means cases are often indequately investigated, which means the jury often sentences without hearing about relevent mitigating evidence.

  2. [...] Override in Capital Cases  Filed under AL govt at work, Law and courts email author :: 5 comments(1577) These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new webpages. [...]

  3. Kathy says:

    Thanks, Wheeler. You’d think when even the Birmingham News questions the application of the death penalty in Alabama, the legislature would take notice. Or not, I guess.

  4. chris says:

    This is Alabama, where over 70% of the population strongly supports the death penalty.

    wow, so they’re not pro-life, huh? I never would have guessed.

  5. Kathy says:

    “wow, so they’re not pro-life, huh? I never would have guessed.”

    Really. :(

  6. Pro-life advocates, such as Ambassador Alan Keyes, explain pro-life as being anti-death penalty for innocent life. However, for the convicted murderer, his capital punishment reafirms the sanctity of the innocent life he snuffed out.

    Can capital punishment be abused? Like anything else where human beings are a factor. However, no State executes a swift capital sentence, which many, including wise old Solomon, believe contributes to growth in crime.

    Though God knew that an innocent person could be unjustly punished (ie. Jesus), He saw the value gained for society by institutionalizing capital punishment. Perhaps the criminal justice system has become just a system and its core needs to be overhauled, instead of attacking a sympton of its imbalance.

  7. Monique says:

    Excellent, what a blog it is! This website presents
    helpful facts to us, keep it up.

  8. Rolland says:

    I do not even know how I ended up here, but I
    thought this post was great. I don’t know who you are but certainly you are going to a famous blogger if you aren’t already ;) Cheers!

  9. all the time i used to read smaller articles or reviews that as well clear their motive,
    and that is also happening with this paragraph which I am reading at this time.

  10. Wow, that’s what I was searching for, what a material! present here at this
    blog, thanks admin of this site.

  11. Herpes can be a sexually transmitted disease which is generally known as STD.
    Herpes currently is dispersing in much bigger population now many persons
    suffer from this illness.
    It happens your skin in the form of small along with small pimples so you think the particular are pimples but you are wrong these are the
    indicators of herpes virus or this can be the sexually fed disease Hsv simplex virus.
    This disease is scattering across 1000s of people
    very quickly on earth and likewise this disease has grown popular throughout the
    world’s folks. It is going to be cured in a few time and very efficiently and you’ll get gone this
    illness. This disease has a lot of curing methods and some are
    popular that can cure anyone very fastly and incredibly efficiently.
    Herpes is that disease which can make your confront very bad plus your skin tone.
    The symptoms on the disease are classified as the painfull swallowing and also some irritation and
    get rid of the Disease because of the treatment given by doctor or you can
    get help via our site and you’ll get the actual cure of the disease very best from
    our own site in addition to our site provides the best plus the efficient
    method to lose this sickness.

Leave a Reply